How To Take Investing Seriously & Stop Playing With Your Money

Don McDonald

WealthFit Contributor

Despite boasts of market-beating performance by many active mutual fund managers after any given period, what isn’t mentioned is the enormous impact of sheer luck.
For a variety of reasons (from the power of our egos to the desire to make a profit from perceived expertise) we often mistake luck for skill.

Did you ever play the stock game in school?

It’s a classroom exercise—typically played in middle school. Students are told to do their own research and choose stocks they believe will enjoy the biggest share price gain over the course of a few weeks.

The kids will typically pick a company they know well: a video game company, a popular retailer, an electronics firm, or their favorite fast food chain. Once their time is up, the player whose stock price rises the most is crowned the smartest “investor.”

But is this investing or are students learning how to gamble?

Unless the child picked their stock based on illegal insider information gleaned off mom or dad, there is no way these kids could possibly know which stocks would rise over the course of a few weeks.

Even if they’d somehow spent most of their young lives studying stocks charts and dissecting quarterly earnings reports, their predictive knowledge would still fall short of the thousands of stock analysts by a giant margin.

The winner of this game isn’t smarter than the other players. He or she was merely more fortunate.

In other words?

The best stock picker was really just the luckiest stock guesser.

A distinction which does make them almost as qualified as about 99% of all US mutual fund managers.

Stocks: The Luck of the Draw?

Do you know anyone (possibly someone you see daily in a mirror) who claims to have picked a stock just before it enjoyed a dramatic increase?

Is it more likely they somehow have access to better stock research and timing skills than, say, a Goldman Sachs analyst—or that they got lucky?

Consider this: In 2017, in the United States alone, there were over 6 billion shares of stock traded every day.

Millions of trades went up in value, and millions of others went down.

On average, there have been 3 years in which the US stock market has risen for every 1 year the market has declined. It seems likely that a lot of stock pickers are merely reaping the benefits of lucky guesses.

Rather than rely on a reasoned thought process, let’s instead turn to academia.

In 2006, the Swiss Finance Institute published the results of a study conducted on the ten-year performance of all actively managed US equity mutual funds and adjusted the results to eliminate the impact of luck.

They found that, after expenses, skill could only account for a mere 0.6% of the market-beating performance of these “expert” managers.

A few years later, a study conducted at the University of Chicago discovered that over 22 years (1984-2009), no more than 3% of active equity mutual fund managers exhibited an ability to beat the market after deducting expenses and adjusting for random chance.

Dozens of studies have shown that beating the market by picking or trading stocks is no more (and maybe even less) likely than winning money at a casino.

Yet, a majority of investors continue to hunt for “hot stocks” or believe that they can find a skilled fund manager. There are even some “investors” (read: gamblers) who try and make a killing day trading equities or, even worse, options contracts.

The Harsh Reality

Maybe you suspect, as many of the ultra-rich seem to believe, that there are some extra-special money managers who possess secret skills reserved for exclusively for the elite. If only you could gain access to the brilliant minds behind hedge funds . . .

In 2007, Warren Buffett bet a well-known hedge fund manager $1 million that, over 10 years, the S&P 500 would outperform a basket of the best hedge funds. A decade later, buying and holding the 500 biggest US firms returned an average of 7.1% per year, while the hand-picked portfolio of the most elite hedge funds made an average of 2.2% per year.

Not only did Buffett’s charity collect $1 million, but those who invested with those hedge funds paid around 2% per year and 20% of their profits for the unique privilege of making about half what a ten-year Treasury note would have returned over the same period.

Here’s the bad news: You are NOT a skilled stock picker!

There are no special investments for special people like you. You are as likely to get rich playing the stock market as might be playing roulette.

So, What Should You Do?

Stop playing with your money and start investing it.

That means taking advantage of the fact that the global economy has always grown more valuable over time. Understand that there will never be significant gains without some occasional pain.

Anything that can’t grow itself or pay a dividend is not an investment. That means that—in most cases—gold, commodities, options, and cryptocurrencies are gambles.

As you’re building your paper portfolio, balance it with securities that have growth potential, like stocks—based on your tolerance for risk and volatility.

That means that you should only buy individual stocks if you are willing to lose everything you invested.

Is the real possibility of a total loss comfortable?

Probably not.

The most reasonable paper investment strategy is simple: Determine your level of loss aversion and create a portfolio consisting of global stocks and high-quality shorter maturity bonds based on historical declines (see chart).

Then, leave it alone until you either need it or your risk profile changes.


1 WSJ Market Data Group

6 10-year US treasury note yield on 12/24/17 4.11%


Written By

Don McDonald

Host of the popular, nationally syndicated “Don McDonald Show” from 1988 until 2007, Don McDonald has been one of the country’s biggest advocates for individual investors.

Read more about Don




live talk
How To Invest and Profit From Real Estate Notes

If you’re looking to invest in real estate, but you don’t want to be a landlord or flip houses, there is another investment option that boasts significant deal flow, low competition, and great pricing. These are the benefits of real estate notes. Even better, you don’t need a ton of money to get started!

6 Options Trading Strategies for 2021

Utilize these 6 options trading strategies whether the markets are bullish, bearish, stagnant or volatile.

live talk
Finding Your First Real Estate Deal

Ammon has 15 years of investing experience with 10 years of in-the-trenches real estate. He also teaches beginners how to get started with confidence.

live talk
Using Index Funds to Maintain Your Wealth

“Index funds are the most no brainer investment alive,” Minesh says in this live talk. “They are a license to stay wealthy.”

live talk
Making Smarter Decisions With Your Money

JP says that if he can educate a teen and help that person avoid making a financial mistake or encourage them to take advantage of a financial opportunity, then his work is worth it. 

live talk
Investing in Defaults, Foreclosures, and Distressed Properties Due to COVID-19

There are many questions swirling about the lasting economic impact of the Covid-19 pandemic. For real estate investors, one of those questions is how to invest in defaults, foreclosures, and properties with distressed sellers. More importantly, how can you do so the right and ethical way?

live talk
Learn How To Cashflow Gold with Scrap Metal

Because scrap gold has to undergo a refining process, many people don’t know the process, how to sell scrap gold, or even its real value. With the right training, you can buy scrap gold and sell it for a HUGE profit.

live talk
Generating Passive Income in Real Estate

Learn why Paul Shively thinks residential real estate is a hedge against market turbulence.

live talk
Investing In Real Estate With Little To No Money

Has a lack of money kept you from investing in real estate? If so, you’re not alone. Angela Gregg had the same thought. But then she decided to educate herself on creative ways to invest. After finding a form of financing called a “Subject To”, she utilized her education and made a whopping $205,000 on her first deal — while investing none of her own money.

How to Buy a House Without a Realtor

Follow this 8-step process to buy your dream home while avoiding paying hefty fees to a realtor. Also, learn how to find the right real estate attorney and the best inspectors.

Options Trading Made Simple

Learn what it means to trade options — and the strategies and tools you need to get started.

A Beginner’s Guide to Investing in Oil & Gas

Learn the top 6 ways to invest in oil or gas from anywhere — PLUS discover the specific tax advantages to petroleum investing.

Investing 101 for Teens
The Simple Guide To REITs: How To Invest In Real Estate With Less Risk & Regular Returns

Thinking about investing in a Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT)? Learn what they are, how they work, and how to pick the best one for you.

Building a Strong Financial Foundation
Invest Like Warren
Cash Flow The Stock Market
Stock Investing 101
Before You Invest
Facebook Live Marketing
Facebook Messenger Marketing
The Short & Simple Guide to Employee Stock Options

What are employee stock options and how do you use them? It's simpler than you might think.

From Zero to Hero: Get a Financial Education & Start Investing Right

You don’t have money—yet. Learn how to begin businesses, invest in real estate, and make your start in the stock market from scratch.

7 Ways to Invest in Real Estate With Little Money

Any cash you put in a real estate investment is cash you can’t use elsewhere. Here are 7 ideas to get that upfront cash as low as possible.