How to Insure Against Disability and Job Loss

Lance Cothern

WealthFit Contributor

If you’re like most Americans, you’ve probably insured your home and your cars — maybe even your life. But there’s one big asset you’re probably forgetting, and it’s with you all the time: your earning potential. Your earning potential could be worth millions of dollars, and without income protection insurance, you’re leaving it unprotected like a phone with no case.

[ DOWNLOAD: Worried about losing your income? Get our Job Loss Protection Packet to start preparing for unexpected hits to your bottom line ]

Since you rely on your future income, doesn’t it make sense for you to insure your future earning potential? 

While it’s not a pleasant thought, it’s important to prepare in the case something happens that makes it impossible for you to work. 

Thankfully, there are options in the United States. 

In this article, we will explain income protection insurance — such as disability insurance and job loss insurance — what you need to know about them and whether or not you should have it. 

What Is Disability Insurance and How Does It Work?

One form of income protection insurance is disability insurance. 

Disability insurance comes in two major forms in the United States: 

  • short-term disability insurance 
  • long-term disability insurance

Sometimes disability insurance is offered as a benefit by employers the way some employers pay for life insurance

Most likely, though, it will be offered as an optional benefit or as a separate policy you’ll have to buy on your own. 


Short-term disability insurance will typically cover you for 9 to 52 weeks with a waiting period of up to 14 days, depending on your policy. During this time you may have to go without pay or dip into your paid time off before receiving any short-term disability payments.

How Much Will Disability Insurance Pay?

Short Term

Short-term disability benefits probably won’t replace your full paycheck. They’ll typically only cover 40 to 80 percent of your base pay.

Long Term

Long-term disability won’t cover you in the short-term but it will kick in after you’ve been disabled for a longer period of time — typically 30 days to a couple years. 

Depending on your policy, long-term disability insurance may pay out for a couple years or until you hit a predetermined retirement age

Like short-term disability insurance, long-term disability insurance only replaces a percentage of your base pay. Unlike short-term disability insurance, that percentage rarely exceeds 60 percent.

How Much Does Disability Insurance Cost?

If disability is included in your work benefits, you’ll pay nothing. Otherwise the pricing for both short-term disability insurance and long-term disability insurance vary. 

Note: if an employer offers disability insurance but doesn’t pay for it, the rates are whatever the benefits program states. 

You have the freedom to window shop if you’re buying disability insurance on your own. A few items can affect the premiums of privately purchased policies: 

  • your health
  • your occupation
  • your salary
  • the benefits you choose

Both short and long-term disability insurance cost about the same amount, typically 1-3% of your annual income.

The important thing is finding a policy that fits your specific needs. 

How to Access Disability Insurance

The process for accessing disability insurance is simple if you receive it through your employer. In most cases, all you’ll need to do is sign up during your benefits open enrollment period. 

Buying short or long-term disability insurance privately is a bit trickier. Luckily, there’s a simple step-by-step you can follow.  

First, you’ll need to decide what type of coverage you want on your policy— do you want coverage for a few weeks or a few years? Do you want to be covered based on loss of any income or based on loss of a specific occupation?

Next, get quotes from different insurance providers in order to scout out the best deal for you.

Once you find a company you’re happy with, apply for disability insurance. 

In the application, you’ll need to share some information about yourself. 

Here’s what you’ll need to apply:

Know Your Medical History

You’ll have to share information about your medical history so the insurer can determine if you have any pre-existing conditions that would stop you from accessing disability insurance. 

For example, illnesses caused by addiction to drugs or alcohol will not qualify you for coverage.

If you pass the application part of the process, you’ll then go through a medical exam to double check your health and medical information. 

Verify Your Income 

The insurance company will also request that you verify your income with pay stubs, W-2s, or a tax return

Once everything is settled, you’ll get a copy of your policy which you must sign and return to the insurer to complete the process.

Taxability of Disability Insurance

Depending on how you pay for your disability insurance, the benefit payments could be either taxable or non-taxable. 

You’ll need to pay taxes on your disability insurance if it’s covered through your work — meaning that either your employer pays the premium or you pay out of your paycheck with pre-tax dollars. 

The exception here is if your employer adds the cost of disability insurance to your total income. 

If they do this, you’ll pay taxes on the extra income but the disability insurance proceeds will be non-taxable. 

If you make your payments with post-tax dollars, your disability income will be non-taxable. 

Consult with a tax professional to determine the taxability of your particular disability insurance.

Which Disability Insurance is Right for You?

It often makes more sense to buy long-term disability insurance over short-term disability insurance. That being said, both types of insurance have their perks. 

Short-term disability insurance is helpful in the event of an accident or illness that will leave you temporarily disabled — think post-surgery recovery time or a bad flu. 

Short-term disability will cover anything that will stop you from working for a little while with the expectation that you’ll return to work once you’re all better.

One of the upsides of short-term disability is that it is more common than long-term disability, which means you’ll have a better chance at a claim. 

The downside? 

The total payout is limited by the policy and will only last for a certain period of time. 

If you’re good at saving, you may want to opt for an emergency fund over short-term disability insurance. It will likely be just as helpful when it comes to covering you and you won’t need to worry about premiums. 

Long-term disability insurance, on the other hand, could provide you with income for decades should you become permanently disabled. Long-term disabilities are typically more serious. 

They include conditions like:

  • traumatic brain injuries
  • cancer
  • mental disorders

Of course, the length of the payout will be determined by the policy you choose and your specific disability. It’s worth it though. 

The need to replace income if you’re permanently disabled and can never return to work is far more serious than replacing your income due to a temporary disability. 

What Is Job Loss Insurance and How Does It Work?

Another form of income protection insurance is job loss insurance. This is rare in the United States. While you may qualify for unemployment benefits from your State or Federal Government, this is not a position anybody wants to be in. 

So what can you do? 

Supplemental Unemployment Insurance

Unemployment insurance, or supplemental unemployment insurance, is an insurance policy that you can buy for yourself to substitute your paycheck if you lose your job. 

Typically, this insurance will allow you some extra cash on top of unemployment benefits from the State or Federal Government or a severance package provided by your employer.

Here are two examples of companies that offer unemployment insurance: 

  • IncomeAssure 
  • SafetyNet

While they both are presently closed to new applications, they are still fulfilling services to current policyholders. 

To help you understand these types of policies, let’s take a closer look at SafetyNet specifically. 

They previously offered private insurance against unemployment — but only in certain states. You could call it layoff insurance. SafetyNet serviced the following states: 

  • Colorado
  • Georgia
  • Iowa
  • Michigan
  • Mississippi
  • Missouri
  • North Carolina
  • Oklahoma
  • South Carolina
  • Wisconsin 


SafetyNet defines job loss as “Job loss due to layoff, business closing, job elimination, or other employer-initiated separation, unless specifically excluded,” and offers a lump sum payment ranging from $1.5K to $9K in the event you lose your job or become disabled and are unable to work. 

They will pay once for disability and once for job loss in one policy year and offer a lifetime maximum benefit of $24K. 

They also have a lengthy list of exclusions on their website. SafetyNet ensures that the specific policy you sign up for includes a full list of exclusions and defines what is and what is not covered by this type of insurance.


Customers who currently own a policy with SafetyNet make monthly payments from $4.50 to $60 per month depending on their coverage and the state they reside in.

Unfortunately, this type of job loss insurance is only a band-aid fix. 

SafetyNet only offers lump sum payment options. For current policyholders, it isn’t going to pay rent — or even grocery bills — for long, so they will need to prioritize returning to work or getting a new job to refill their pockets. 

Taxability of Unemployment Insurance

Unlike disability claims, SafetyNet issues a 1099 to unemployment claimants. This means that the income through this policy is indeed taxable. 

When Should You Consider Job Loss Insurance?

The fact that both of these companies are no longer taking new clients tells you the market condition of job loss insurance. 

So what should you do instead?

Ideally, you want an emergency fund to cover the expenses from disability or job loss. 

After all, money in the bank is the best income protection against short-term injuries or illnesses. 

Another factor to consider: while you can’t control every situation, you can control your health to an extent. Be proactive in taking care of your body:

Do You Need Income Protection Insurance?

Now that you know your options, you can decide if you’re ready to insure your earning potential with income protection insurance. 

Depending upon your employment and your health, it may make sense to buy short-term disability or long-term disability, as income protection insurance.

Or, you may decide that an emergency fund will best fit your needs. 

Sit down with a financial advisor and discuss these options. 

By planning for the unexpected, not only will you be prepared if the worst strikes: you’ll be able to rest easy in the meantime. 

Continued Learning

If you want to learn more about income protection insurance, other forms of insurance and increasing your financial knowledge, here are a few free resources: 

[ DOWNLOAD: Worried about losing your income? Get our Job Loss Protection Packet to start preparing for unexpected hits to your bottom line ]


Written By

Lance Cothern

Lance Cothern is a freelance writer and founder of the personal finance blog Money Manifesto.

Read more about Lance




How To Get Help With Medical Debt: 6 Organizations That Will Pay Your Medical Bills in 2021

Learn how to get help paying down your medical debt — and how to avoid racking up unnecessary debt in the first place.

How Much You (Really) Should Save Each Month 

Learn how much you need to save each month—if you want to get ahead. If you can’t save 20% of your income . . . you need to make more money!

Do You Have Too Much Student Debt? Use This Rule To Figure It Out

Learn how to calculate if you have too much student loan debt and how to permanently lower your student loan debt.

How To Do A Balance Transfer: The RIGHT Way

Learn how to do a balance transfer that lowers your interest rate, saves you money, boosts your credit score, and gets you out of debt fast.

How to Write A Goodwill Letter That WORKS [Templates Included]

Is a late payment hurting your credit score? There's good news: you write a goodwill letter and ask the creditor to take it off your credit history.

The BIG Difference Between a Roth IRA & a Traditional IRA

IRAs are great ways to save for retirement. But this one difference will determine whether or you want a Traditional or a Roth IRA.

10 Low-Cost Alternatives to Cable TV

Cutting your cable bill is an easy way to save tons of money. If you have home internet you already have access to on demand entertainment.

When "Penny Hoarding" Goes Wrong ...

Saving money is great—but not if it costs you something more valuable: your time.

live talk
Analyzing the Changes in US Economy Due to Covid-19

With the financial impacts of Covid-19 pandemic continuing to affect the health of individuals, the economy, investments, businesses of all sizes and more, many have burning questions about what the economic future holds. 

live talk
Discover How to Use Life Insurance to Accelerate Your Retirement Timeline

There is a way to leave your family in financial peace and pass on more than you were able to generate or save throughout your life time: life insurance.

live talk
Student Debt, ‘On The Side’ Income & Investing Quickstart

Robert Farrington takes us through his journey from working at Target, to hitting his target investment goals. Helping millennials get out of student loan debt and accept personal accountability for their money, his expertise is shared to help build wealth through investing.

live talk
Quit Like a Millionaire

Imagine retiring in your 30's and traveling the world on permanent vacation. Kristy Shen and Bryce Leung live this lifestyle and sit down with Dustin to explain how you can do the same. By going against the norm, investing their money, and quitting their jobs, tune in as they share helpful tips from their new book, Quit Like a Millionaire.

live talk
Do You Have A Powerful Money Mindset?

Dustin sits down with Military Money Expert, Lacey Langford, as she drills the importance of getting your personal finances up to military standards, without all of the yelling. An Army brat, financial expert, military wife, and veteran all rolled into one, Lacey is on a mission to help combat the fear around money.

More Cashflow, Less Stress
Master Your Cashflow
Financial Adulting
live talk
What’s Your Money Operating System®?

Hilary Hendershott shares what really causes financial trouble and how she was able to get out of debt as a financial advisor.

Zero Student Debt
live talk
A Candid Conversation with a Private Banker

Discover more about the controversial topics about money and banking your banker probably won't talk to you about. Also, find out where the finance world is headed.

The Early Retirement Blueprint
Pay Less Taxes
live talk
Getting Yourself In the Flow of Wealth

Justin Faerman on the flow of creating wealth and avoiding the massive sacrifices that our parents, programming, or society expect of us.

The Hidden Power of Life Insurance
Wealth That Lasts