Why Did My Credit Score Drop? 4 Reasons for Your Lower Credit Score You Haven't Even Considered

Michelle Black

WealthFit Contributor

Think earning and keeping a stellar credit score is simple? Think again. Sure, there are some basic principles to follow to keep your credit score up — pay your bills on time, avoid collection accounts and repos, etc. But there are also some lesser-known​ mistakes that could send your scores crashing through the floor before you even have the chance to catch them.

You know a thing or two about keeping your credit scores up and your tradelines healthy. But sometimes that isn’t enough.

Since you want the highest credit scores possible (you really do—it’ll save you money), it's smart to know what unusual credit mistakes you can make are now.

Here are the 4 main credit mistakes so you can stop yourself from making them.

1. Your Credit Card Balance Is Higher

Did you know that carrying a balance on your credit cards could hurt your credit scores—even if you’ve never miss a payment on the account?

Sit tight. There’s an explanation coming your way.

Credit scoring models, like FICO and VantageScore, pay close attention to the percentage of credit limit you use on revolving accounts (like credit cards). In the credit world, this is called your revolving utilization ratio. The lower your revolving utilization, the better. At least from a credit scoring perspective.

How to calculate revolving utilization ratio

Revolving utilization is responsible for a big chunk of your FICO credit scores—30% of it, to be exact. That's nearly one-third of your total available points. Revolving utilization is also listed as "highly influential" upon your VantageScores.

When your credit card balances increase, the revolving utilization ratio can raise on your credit reports. This can cause your scores to go down, maybe by a lot.

If you want to maintain stellar credit scores, paying off your credit cards in full every month is non-negotiable. Period. Plus, paying off credit card balances each month makes perfect financial sense—unless you get your kicks throwing away hard-earned money on expensive interest fees.

Can’t afford to pay off all your debt at once? Try to consolidate your credit card debt and if any remains, you can use debt snowball method.

2. You're Paying At the Wrong Time of the Month

Are you already smart about your credit card management habits? Do you pay off your entire credit card balances each month to avoid expensive interest fees?

That's great, but here’s some bad news.

If you wait until the due date to pay your card balance down to $0, you're paying the bill too late.

The account balances on your credit reports are not updated in real time. This means that the balances on your credit reports aren't going to change the second you make a payment or a charge.

Instead, your credit card accounts are updated with credit bureaus just once a month. Your reports are updated with Equifax, TransUnion, and Experian shortly after what is known as the statement closing date.

The statement closing date signals the end of your monthly billing cycle. Your closing date is the date your billing statement is created and your account balance (plus minimum payment) is set for the month.

The credit card balance that winds up on your credit reports is the balance reflected on this monthly statement.

To allow the payment time to post, pay your balance off a few days before the statement closing date. This way you should see a $0 balance and 0% utilization on your reports for the next 30 days.

You can also achieve 0% utilization (a smart move for your credit scores) by paying off your card in full. Afterwards, put all new charges on ice for at least one full billing cycle.

Either option works. Pick your favorite.

3. You Closed a Credit Card Account

Maybe you’ve heard that closing a credit card account will hurt your scores because you’re losing your credit for the age of your closed account.

That’s a myth. Well, a half-myth.

The real reason closing your credit card could tank your scores is potential revolving utilization problems.

Scoring models are designed to consider both the revolving utilization on your individual accounts along with your overall revolving utilization. Both factors matter when your scores are calculated.

How to calculate overall revolving utilization

When you close a credit card with an available credit limit, that limit stops getting factored into your overall revolving utilization ratio.

The result?

You could accidentally raise your utilization rate. That's not so hot for your credit scores.

Example of overall revolving utilization

In this example, closing down a credit card seems to have been the absolute wrong move in terms of credit. It raised overall revolving utilization nearly 50%.

Be careful to consider the fallout before you cut your card.

4. Your Card Issuer Lowered Your Credit Limit

By now you're probably starting to pick up on a theme.

Many unexpected credit score drops have something to do with credit cards. If your credit score drops with no apparent explanation, the first place you should look is the credit card section of your credit reports. If you find any missed reports, a goodwill letter might be the move.

Sometimes credit card issuers lower credit limits. This might be in response to something troubling on your credit reports (even on unrelated accounts), a drop in your credit scores, or maybe you're just not using your account enough.

Regardless of the reason, if your card issuer lowers the credit limit on your account, the result can be a higher revolving utilization ratio on your reports. When your overall credit limit is lowered, revolving utilization increases unless all of your credit cards have $0 balances.

At the risk of repetition—higher revolving utilization is bad, lower revolving utilization is good. If you can master this concept while keeping your bills paid on time, you'll be well on your way to a brag-worthy credit score before you know it.  


Written By

Michelle Black

Michelle Black is a credit expert with over 16 years of experience in the industry and a freelance writer.

Read more about Michelle




How to Create a “Simple” Budget

Discover how to create a simple budget — and 7 specific ways to make it stick.

Stuck With a Bad Car Loan? Here’s How to Get Out of It

Learn 3 ways to get out of a car loan without hurting your credit score.

What Is Credit Card Debt “Forgiveness”?

Learn the many ways to get part (... or even ALL) of your credit card debt permanently forgiven.

What Can You Do With A 700 Credit Score?

Discover what you can and can’t do with a 700 credit score. Then, learn how to grow your score to get more funding and lower interest rates.

How To Get Your First Credit Card

Follow this step-by-step guide to learn how and when to get your first credit card and start building your credit score.

How Hard Inquiries Affect Your Credit Score

Learn how hard inquiries affect your credit score and how to minimize the damage when shopping for a car, a house, or a personal loan.

How To Use A Credit Card To Build [Or Fix!] Your Credit Score

Learn a step-by-step process to build (or fix!) your credit fast with a credit card—pick the right card and use it wisely.

How To Improve Your Credit Score In 30 Days

Want to improve your credit score fast? Learn 3 different strategies to improve your credit score in 30 days or less.

live talk
Analyzing the Changes in US Economy Due to Covid-19

With the financial impacts of Covid-19 pandemic continuing to affect the health of individuals, the economy, investments, businesses of all sizes and more, many have burning questions about what the economic future holds. 

live talk
Discover How to Use Life Insurance to Accelerate Your Retirement Timeline

There is a way to leave your family in financial peace and pass on more than you were able to generate or save throughout your life time: life insurance.

live talk
Student Debt, ‘On The Side’ Income & Investing Quickstart

Robert Farrington takes us through his journey from working at Target, to hitting his target investment goals. Helping millennials get out of student loan debt and accept personal accountability for their money, his expertise is shared to help build wealth through investing.

live talk
Quit Like a Millionaire

Imagine retiring in your 30's and traveling the world on permanent vacation. Kristy Shen and Bryce Leung live this lifestyle and sit down with Dustin to explain how you can do the same. By going against the norm, investing their money, and quitting their jobs, tune in as they share helpful tips from their new book, Quit Like a Millionaire.

live talk
Do You Have A Powerful Money Mindset?

Dustin sits down with Military Money Expert, Lacey Langford, as she drills the importance of getting your personal finances up to military standards, without all of the yelling. An Army brat, financial expert, military wife, and veteran all rolled into one, Lacey is on a mission to help combat the fear around money.

More Cashflow, Less Stress
Master Your Cashflow
Financial Adulting
live talk
What’s Your Money Operating System®?

Hilary Hendershott shares what really causes financial trouble and how she was able to get out of debt as a financial advisor.

Zero Student Debt
live talk
A Candid Conversation with a Private Banker

Discover more about the controversial topics about money and banking your banker probably won't talk to you about. Also, find out where the finance world is headed.

The Early Retirement Blueprint
Pay Less Taxes
live talk
Getting Yourself In the Flow of Wealth

Justin Faerman on the flow of creating wealth and avoiding the massive sacrifices that our parents, programming, or society expect of us.

The Hidden Power of Life Insurance
Intro to Credit